获取最新资讯与技术支持
13572817195
123456789@qq.com
获取每日最新科技资讯与行业报告
1 Introduction
Generally, the antenna radome on the aircraft is one of the most vulnerable part in the event of lightning strike, its material is usually non-conductive composite material or insulating resin material. Considering the requirements of wave-transparent, the most common way to protect the radome is to use diverter strips. The layout mode, numbers and length of the strips all can affect the lightning protection effect. We need to consider whether the strips pasted on the radome will impact wave-transparent property or not. Differentforms of diverter strips (solid metal diverter strips and segmented diverterstrips) also have different impacts to antenna. In this paper,we give a comparison between the solid metal diverter strips and a new type of segmented diverter strips, Using test method and simulation method, to determine the optimum lightning protection design of radome. The lightning tests in this paper were performed according to SAE-ARP5416A.Some key radomes are located in Zone 1 (initial attachment region) in general, The internal metal materials (antenna, holder etc.) will affect the space electric field in lightning environment, the lightning flash maybe guided to the metal materials, and then breakdown the radome skin. In order to avoid the lightning damage to the antennaand the radome, it’s necessary to paste certain quantities of diverter strips to intercept the lightning channel and transfer away the lightning current. The traditional diverter strips are made of conductive metal materials, such as copper, aluminum, etc. In order to ensure the antenna communication, more and more segment diverter strips are used on radome.
2 Diverter strips layout design
A. Segmented diverter strips
The radome of an aircraft, an ideal location for radar and glideslope antennas, is highly vulnerable to lightning strikes. A strike usually causes antenna and/oravionics damage, as well as severe radome damage. If the hit is severe, the aircraft can be endangered by flying debris, excessive drag, loss of radar capability, and false air speed indications because of change in airflow.
Radome design engineers are now using segmented diverter strips to enhance the lightning protection of both existing and new radome designs. Segmented diverterstrips consist of a line of small metal segments on a flexible substrate that, when exposed to lightning conditions, form a conductive plasma channel above their surface to direct the lightning energy toward grounded metal structure. Their function is illustrated in Fig.1.
Fig.1. The arrangement figure of the lightning strike test to the radome.
B. Model design
The radome lightning protection performance is not only depend on the diverter strips arrangement direction, numbers, length, but also influenced by the antenna position, rotation angle, and the distance between the antenna and radome skin. Because of these factors, analytical or empirical formula calculation is difficult to measure protection scope accurately, while numerical calculation can handle these factors better, so the numerical method is applied in this paper.
The simulation tool used in this paper is the finite element numerical calculation software COMSOL Multiphysics AC/DC module. The research object is a real part of radome (Fig.2), the electrode is above the fiber glass, solid metal block was used to simulate antenna, segmented diverter strips arepasted on the fiber glass horizontally. The radius of the cylinder is 70cm, thelength is 110cm, the width is 71cm (curved distance). The width of the metal frame is 4.0cm. The distance between segmented diverter strips is 50cm(curved distance). The distance between the upper antenna and the inner surface of radome skin is 8.3cm.The distance between the electrode and the radome skinis 30cm to 70cm.
The following factors should be considered in the set up of simulation model:
Fig. 2. Model design.
C. Lightning channel analysis
There are 3 possible lightning channels, shown as Fig.3:
If the lightning channel is channel 2 or channel3, not channel 1, the following condition should be satisfied:
(1)
K is defined as lightning channel coefficient. U1 is the electrical potential of the electrode. U2 is the upper surface electrical potential of the radome directly facing the electrode. U3 is the inner surface electrical potential of the radome directly facing the electrode, its value depends on the relative position of the electrode H, the distance h, environmental factors, resistive coefficient of skin and coating.
Fig.3. Lightning channel presentation drawing.
The critical state of the channel 1, channel 2 and channel 3 is represented as:
(2)
Kc represents the critical channel coefficient.
If the lightning channel is channel 3,not channel 2:
(3)
d is the thickness of the cylinder, h is the nearest distance between the radome skin and the antenna, L is the nearest distance between the diverter strips and the central position of the cylinder, Ed is the breakdown intensity of the random, EL is the breakdown intensity along the cylinder, EC isthe breakdown intensity of the segmented diverter strip. The test indicates that the breakdown intensity of the segmented diverter strips can be ignored while being compared to the breakdown intensity of the air, so EC can be replaced by 0. The value of Ed, EL need to be confirmed by the test.
D. Method and procedure
The test is arranged according to Fig.2. The initial distance is 70cm, then move electrode close to radome skin until the skin is breakdown. Both the positive and negative polarity are tested.
The simulation model is established according to the Fig.1. Hvary from 30cm to 70cm.
Specific procedures:
3 Computation of the influence of diverter strips to antenna gain
In order to test the influence to the antenna, put the high frequency horn antenna under the radome without diverter strips and the radome with diverter strips(solid metal diverter strips and segmented diverter strips) respectively, then compute the results of all configurations. Fig.4 and Fig.5 is the antenna pattern of the horn antenna whose central frequency is 4GHz, the antenna is placed vertically.
The Fig.4 indicates that solid metal strips have more influence to the antenna gain, especially in the direction arranged with strips. The power in the principle direction was pressed to the sidelobe(Fig.4b). The segmented diverter strips have less influence (Fig.4c). From Fig. 5 we can see that the sidelobe gain has about 20dB decrease compared with gain of no strips(Fig.5a) when solid metal strips are arranged in direction of phi = 0deg.There is 2 dB ~3dB influence to the mainlobe gain when phi=90deg(Fig.5b), while theinfluence of the segment strips is very little.
Fig.4. The influence of the diverter strips to the antenna gain(omnidirectional). (a) Nodiverter strips. (b) Solid metal strips. (c) Segment diverter strips.
Fig.5. The influence of the diverter strips to the antenna gain (principle direction) . (a) Phi = 0 deg. (b) Phi = 90 deg.
4 Experimental verification
A. The verification of layout method of the segmented strips
The experimental results arelisted in table 1:
TABLE I. Experimental statistical table
It is observed from table 1:
When h (the distance between antenna and radome skin) is 11cm, H (the distance between electrode and radome skin) is 55cm~100cm, there is no breakdown.
When h is 8.3cm, the electrode was breakdown once in the place of 55cm and 50cm respectively. Negative polarity was breakdown once in the place of 40cm.
Fig. 6 is the potential distribution when H is 50cm and h is 8.3cm.
Fig. 6a indicates that thelargest electrical potential is in the center of radome skin. The electrical potential is very small at the area of the solid metal frame and diverterstrips, nearly 0V.
Fig. 6. Electrical potential distribution while H is 50cm.
Change H, then get the electrical potential of the center of inner and outer radome skin, plot a figure as shown in Fig.7a. According to the equation (2), plot the change curve of K, as shown in Fig.7b.
According to the test result, whenthe lightning strike is positive polarity, the radome will be puncturedwhile H is 50cm; when the lightning strike is negative polarity, the radome will be punctured while H is 40cm.
Fig.7. H vs E and H vs K. (a) Electrical potential of the center of inner and outer radome skin. (b) Channel coefficient K.
So when the lightning strike is positive polarity, the critical breakdown channel coefficient Kc is 0.796; when the lightning strike is negative polarity, Kc is 0.746.
In order to verify the above method, paste the diverter strips vertically, keep H as constant (0.5m), change the distances between diverter strips from 0.5m to 1.0m. Then compute the electrical potential distribution of the inner and outer radome skin (Figs.8 and 9) and different K in thecondition of different diverter strips distances (Fig.10). Fig.10 indicates that the critical distance between diverter strips will change with H.
Fig.8. Electrical potential distribution of the radome skin when H is 0.5m, the diverter strips distance is 0.7 m (kV).
Fig.9. The electrical potential of the center of inner and outer random skin in different diverter strips distances (H is0.55 m, 0.50 m and 0.45 m).
Fig.10. The channel coefficient changein different diverter strips distances (the distance between electrode and random skin is 0.55m, 0.50m and 0.45m).
Finally, we find the test result is the same as the computation result, it proved that the method used in this paper is effective.The typical phenomenon is shown in Fig.11.
Fig.11. Typical test phenomenon. (a) A test segmented strips are pasted horizontal. (b) A test segmented strips are pastedvertically. (c) A test radome is punctured.
Fig.11a is an intercept test where diverter strips are pasted horizontally(channel 1 in Fig.4). The lightning first is guided to the segmented diverter strips successfully, forming a ionization channel on the surface of the segmented diverter strips which is connected to the metal frame. In Fig.11b, the radome skin is punctured by lightning when the layout of the segmented diverter strips is unreasonable (the channel 3 in Fig.4).
If the breakdown voltage of the radome is too small when compared with the breakdown voltage of the air gap(h), In the critical condition,a little move of electrode or strips will lead to the flash channel 1 orchannel 3, Channel 2 is almost impossible to appear.
B. Wave transparent test of diverterstrips
Arrange the diverter strips on the radome, then conduct the wave transparent test in a standard microwave anechoic chamber. The center frequency of the test antenna is 10GHz, The signal is vertical polarization, scan angle rangefrom -60° to 60°,scanspeed is1°/s. The test result is shown in Fig.13.
Fig.12. The layout of segmented strips on radome.
Fig.13. The gain influence of diverter strips to the radome. (a) The comparison of gain without diverter strip and gain with solid metal strips. (b) The comparison of gain without diverter strip and gain with segmented strips.
Fig.13a indicates that solid metal diverter strips have more influence on the antenna gain (4.5dB), the influence of segmented strips is very small(<0.5dB, Fig.13b).
5 Conclusion
扫描二维码添加客服微信
工作时间:周一至周五 9:00-18:00
发送邮件至客服邮箱我们将在24小时内回复